Monday, July 3, 2017

Moving the needle

[Note, this post is not about phylogenies]

I’ve sensed some ‘what’s-the-big-deal’-ness in response to recent discussion about inappropriate behavior at the recent Evolution meetings, so I want to explain why I take this so seriously. I think you should care too, assuming you are interested in making science more diverse and inclusive.  I’ll speak from my own experience here, making this a perhaps uncommonly personal post.  First, I should say that I have been lucky throughout my career to have exceptional mentors (both men and women) who strongly encouraged my interest in science and always made me feel supported.  But early on, it became apparent to me (and my female peers) that being a woman in science was going to present extra challenges. None of my experiences are unique and I have colleagues who had a much harder time*. One thing it seems like we all discovered was the amount of caution that was needed in interacting with male scientists, especially senior ones.  Being friendly was sometimes taken as openness to flirtation, which could escalate to unwanted touching or worse. So as young woman in science, I learned how to tread carefully and how to be friendly but divert conversations when there were red flags. I learned what the flags are (“looks like you’ve been working out!” or “why is someone like you single?”**). I learned to avoid places and situations where inappropriate behavior is likely to happen, even if it meant sometimes missing out on networking***, and I found friends with whom I could safely discuss these issues. Friends who understood that it’s not as simple as ‘not putting up’ with bad behavior, especially from senior scientists in a community that is so tightly woven through letters of recommendation, reviews, grant panels, and committees.

For me, these social acrobatics became part of the fabric of interacting with other scientists. Another skill like presenting posters, or making aesthetically appealing slides.  It wasn’t until a few years ago that I realized how much mental and emotional energy I wasted on these acrobatics as a younger scientist. Energy that I could have devoted to science or something else! Energy that some of my peers never had to spend****. Now that I am a faculty member, inappropriate behavior towards me has become less common, but I worry for my students and other young scientists. I wish I could prevent unprofessional behavior from clouding their experiences. I wish I could save them from the wasted energy of handling those who behave inappropriately. I wish I could keep them from ever having to become social acrobats themselves. They shouldn’t have to. But it doesn’t seem like things have changed that much in the 16 years I’ve been in this field. For my mentees, I try to prepare them, let them know that I know it happens, welcome them to come talk with me about their concerns, and ask them to brainstorm with me on how to make things better.  With regard to the Evolution meetings, the Society for Systematic Biology has called for suggestions. I’m hoping that together we’ll come up with ideas that could actually move the needle.

*To get a sense, peruse the nearly 900 responses to Gina Baucom’s post about crappy things said to or about women in academia.

**I know that these may seem incredibly obvious but when it’s someone senior, someone you respect, and someone that you would never imagine would hit on you, it takes a while (at least for me) to realize what it is.  I have learned now to look past rank and listen to my gut.

***If we want access to science for everyone, no one should have to make these choices.

****These are my experiences but I imagine the same goes for other underrepresented groups in STEM.

11 comments:

  1. As an male advisor of female students it can be hard to provide direct guidance on the social acrobatics. But clearly the answer is not that male professors should only advise male students! So, the question arises, on how best to support female and minority students. Is it good enough to advise female student to also seek out informal female mentors, or at least (as I have advised all my female students), to include at least one female professor on their committees? (and maybe, likewise, for minority students?) Or should we also try and actively discuss sexual harassment as part of the routine mentor-mentee dialog?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi David,

    Thanks for your comment and question! The short answer is yes, the latter! We need male advisors to get involved! And here comes a longer answer, because I bet there are many others with the same question.

    I think suggesting that students from underrepresented groups seek additional mentors from the same group is not necessarily the best option for several reasons. Taking the case of female students:

    >In most departments, female faculty are in the minority and most are probably still working towards becoming full professors. Thus, we wouldn’t want to burden them with additional mentoring (although it happens anyway, and probably contributes to the higher service load often carried by women, google 'academic housekeeping')

    >Women can be sexist, too, so there is no guarantee that a woman will provide good mentorship.

    >One more simple reason is that your mentee chose you. Support and guidance will mean the most coming from you. Sure, you can help connect your student with others (on lots of fronts, and that’s a central role of an advisor), but fundamentally the student looks to you first for leadership.

    So what can a male advisor do? Lots of things! Here are some ideas:

    >As you suggest, when a new mentee (of any background or gender) joins the lab, discuss expectations for being a lab member and make professional behavior a part of this discussion. I wrote up an expectations doc to help me jumpstart these discussions with new students (www.colorado.edu/smithlab/all-about-expectations)

    >Find a time to talk about professional behavior as a lab. After this year, I’ve decided to roll this in to the lab practice talk session. I plan to make this as interactive as possible by providing some examples (e.g. present a scenario and discuss whether this would be unprofessional, would constitute harassment or discrimination) and solicit other examples from the group. I will stress that even if a situation isn’t harassment, it may still be unprofessional and/or create an unwelcoming climate. We all have to work on this, and it only gets better by open discussion. We (as advisors) don’t have to have all the answers, but collectively, with people at all stages, we can all work on figuring out the best approaches.

    >I think the other huge thing that male advisors can do is to stick up for their mentees. When inappropriate or 'othering' comments are made towards a student, say something. There are two challenges here. The first is recognizing these comments as they may not stand out to you. Recently on twitter, Gina Baucom (https://twitter.com/gbaucom/status/872446177580593152) and Aradhna Tripati (https://twitter.com/ClumpedIsotopes/status/883738984534245377) have solicited examples, and there are common themes (https://dynamicecology.wordpress.com/2017/07/06/guest-post-the-day-i-broke-some-twitter-feeds-insights-into-sexism-in-academia-part-1/). The second challenge is having something to say. Gina has made some suggestions in her follow-up post, and even if you miss the moment, you can always ask later if the comment made the student feel uncomfortable and go from there.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. One other thing that may be informative. When I was a student/postdoc, I didn’t discuss these issues with anyone other than friends and other students/postdocs for so many reasons, e.g.:

      >Although I certainly heard plenty of inappropriate comments, I couldn’t have said what constituted harassment.

      >I didn’t want to ‘waste’ the time of anyone senior if I could ‘handle’ it myself.

      >I didn’t want to draw attention to aspects of my experience relating to being a woman. I wanted to keep the focus on the science.

      >There was some part of me that thought I might not be believed or that it might seem like I was ‘blowing something out of proportion’.

      >I didn’t want senior people to be disappointed in their colleagues who engage in inappropriate behavior or lose respect for them.

      >I wasn’t sure where the discussion would go if ever brought up. Either nothing would happen or it might come back to bite me.

      >Overall, I accepted that inappropriate behavior was common and that not much could be done about it.


      Note that little of this would be different if my advisor had been a woman. I would still have had the same notions, and I'm not sure that an informal female mentor would have had the time or level of connection to dissuade me of them. So knowing some of the barriers for students, I think it’s much easier to think about how to set the stage for making a difference. You could allay the concerns laid out above by providing a space for discussion; letting your mentees know that your door is open, you want to hear their conerns, and you will believe them; explaining how reporting works on campus and that you are a mandatory reporter but that what action takes place is their choice; and perhaps most of all, showing that you are clued in by stepping when you hear or see things that are out of line, even when it feels uncomfortable or awkward. It’s a long road but I think stasis will continue unless all PIs chip in to make science more equitable and welcoming, starting with their own labs, departments, and communities.

      Delete
    2. And speaking of always learning more, here is a nice article defining sexism, sexual harassment, sexual discrimination: http://www.stemwomen.net/what-is-sexism/
      Lots of things in there that I didn't know.

      Delete
  3. Online gambling makes you rich.
    จีคลับIs a popular online casino site that has been providing online gambling for more than 10 years with a system that offers the latest casino games. This club is well-known and popular today, and most importantly, the gambling club website. This online casino is also an opportunity to play online casino games in each form is easy to access, and importantly, every player can now play all online gambling games. model You do not have to download the program to play time because the service of the website gclub. This online casino is open to play online gambling games, with just the internet, you can play all kinds of online casino games. The challenge and excitement of this service is open and the system is available in accordance with the age, so all players are able to access online gambling every time anytime. And when you want to play online gambling games, it's just a click bettor on the webRuby888


    ReplyDelete
  4. Nice article great post comment information thanks for sharing

    ดูหนังเกาหลี

    ReplyDelete
  5. Make money online.
    รอยัล1688The website is open to the g club. Casino online casinos where you can play all kinds of luck. The only Internet connection to play. Every time a gambler has a risky internet, he can play all kinds of online casino games on Poipet. This casino. The online casino site. It is another fun and exciting new opportunity for people who are passionate and passionate about gambling and gambling. As a result of this, online gambling in each form is constantly being developed. This makes the game of online betting is now known and popular in it. Whether it is a gambler. Thais or foreigners are passionate about playing online gambling games with each other because online gambling in each form is both fun and easy to play and important to gambling. Online bets are another fun new alternative to bets. Online bets can be played online at any risk through the signal. Whether your preferred remove the risk where they can gamble online. When thinking about gambling online, remember to think of the web service viva3388

    ReplyDelete
  6. Online Gambling Make you rich
    viva9988G-Club Website Online casino named. One of the richest ways that a bettor can not miss because every time a risk comes to play casino games online casino site. Our gambler will know the main reason why most gamblers choose to play online casino games with us. Online gambling in each form is available on the casino web site. Our club is an online gambling that was chosen as well. And more importantly. Playing Online Gambling Games on Casino Websites Our club also has a maximum bonus of up to two hundred thousand baht, so it is not strange that now our online casino has the largest number of members. Admit it as a casino web site. The top clubs that the player chooses to use it. So if you are thinking of playing online casino games, do not forget to choose the web gambling club. Our online casino because we are willing to serve the player every time the bettor wishes. Bets can be found and experience the atmosphere of playing online gambling games with the players around the world all day and night at the site จีคลับ

    ReplyDelete
  7. Casinos meet your needs.
    จีคลับ Online casino games online to bring customers to the rich with gambling games online casino. All online games are designed to meet the needs of modern people. Betting on online gambling games is very easy. With a stable online betting site. Entertainment of the game to win online games that give players the full fun of gambling. The game is easy to understand, so you can gamble online games on our website as expert. Enjoy with you. And new online casino games that allow you to make money from gambling games to win every game. The choice to enjoy the online casino games that bring wealth to you. We are open to all players. Do not miss out on online gambling games that give you an enjoyable enjoyment. There are also new games that keep updating every time, so players do not miss any of the game is coming. Enjoy all the games with online gambling that will make you like to bet on a real live betting venue. บาคาร่า

    ReplyDelete
  8. Bet you can trust.
    Ruby888 Online casino site is a reputation in the field of entertainment. Full casino support. No matter where you are in the world. It can be accessed quickly. It is also a site that has staff to help and advise newcomers or those who are interested in playing 24 hours. In addition, the online casino site has added games and activities. Come on continuously. The game is easy to play to get players in every way has updated the way to play all the time. There are also various playing tips. Keeping the players entertained. The game is transmitted through our online casino site, sharp images without interruption through the Internet. For players to enjoy uninterrupted. In addition, the online games bets on our online casino site. We guarantee that real players pay real money without taking any players. You just want to try playing gambling games rather than playing time kill games. Can be contacted directly through our website. In addition to the speed and accuracy that can be verified. Our casino site is also one of the top casinos. The country with the most shifting players each day. Please join us at the website. IBCbet

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thank you for sharing valuable information. Nice post. I enjoyed reading this post.

    หนังจีน

    ReplyDelete