Monday, May 15, 2017

Back to the future

One of the most pervasive carryovers from ladder-of-life thinking is that some living species are older than others.  These are often thought of as sitting on the lower rungs of the ladder.  Of course, tree-thinking rejects this notion as all living species have evolved the same amount of time from their shared common ancestor at the base.  Nonetheless I hear so many phrases that reflect the continuing influence of ladder-thinking, even among evolutionary biologists.  So here's a good one - 'That trait goes all the way back to echinoderms' [or insert any taxon perceived to be old]. The speaker almost certainly wanted to communicate that the trait was present in the common ancestor of echinoderms and vertebrates.  So what's the problem with using the shorthand 'back to echinoderms'?  Well, it suggests that an echinoderm was the common ancestor of echinoderms and vertebrates (not true even if that ancestor *looked* more like an echinoderm) and/or that echinoderms haven't been evolving since their split with other deuterostomes.  This is particularly dangerous as it often leads to poor experimental design --  using living species perceived to be old or primitive as stand-ins for ancestors.  Certainly studying echinoderms can help us make inferences about that common ancestor, but so would studying any other descendant.

So in summary:



p.s.  I think it would be a little better to say 'out to echinoderms' -- if your listener assumes humans are starting point, then going 'out' to echinoderms spans the clade that captures both humans and echinoderms, which maps to a particular ancestral node.  But why not just use a couple more words and say the trait was present in the common ancestor of deuterostomes.

11 comments:

  1. Online casinos offer rich players.
    GcluIt's the way to go online for online gambling games that can meet your needs, ready for you to play the next real fun online gambling. Online gambling has been broadcast by the famous gambling source of Cambodia. Bet at Poipet Casino Resort Have fun with your taste and exciting. Because of the type of gambling games, the new look is easy to understand. Challenge to deliver a superior gambling experience. Guaranteed the fun of the website that has long been available and is well accepted by gamblers who gamble. We are the leading online casino site in Thailand. Belief is open to all players. There is a dedicated team of experts. Discuss and ask questions. All about gambling games at any time. Take the chance to win the game online to make the user experience the exciting challenge games. Not only this, but also the money from the game. Every game is ready to make rich customers shortcut. The most popular online casino betting sites are waiting for users to take advantage of every moment. Royal1688

    ReplyDelete
  2. Online gambling is packed with all the entertainment.
    จีคลับIt is an online gambling option that is ready to give the user the fun of gambling games in the amazing. New online gambling brings you to the joy of being good. With quality online casino sites and open 24 hours to allow gamblers to enjoy their favorite online gambling every time. Nowadays online lotto is developed to support your fluency. You do not have to download the program because you can gamble on the web directly. The best way to win money online is online. Not only that, you can earn money from every single game, but the odds are very high, depending on your skill and your luck. Can I find a good strategy? Before you risk it so that anyone can bet on it. Play with the money with a new online game with a service without interruption. Easy to play and access to our online games are many channels. Online Gambling Betting is fun and exciting with all the risky games. บาคาร่า

    ReplyDelete
  3. Online Gambling Anyone can play it
    รูบี้888Is a web-based online gambling site with a reputation for fun, open to the joy and fun for more than 10 years, the casino society is known and became accepted in just a few minutes. Long time ago, playing online gambling games was one of the first places of great wealth. Anyone who can join and start rich is not difficult. As a result of playing online gambling games in each form, the player or ordinary people become the highest income in the country and the highest in the world because of the income from playing games. Online casino games are very easy. Since every time a bettor overcame an online gambler, the bettor was able to make an income from playing the online gambling game as well, just as the player bets on the gambling and playing online gambling games. With casino site Our gambling player can make money from playing online gambling with a player around the world if you want to know that money from the online game is very risky. Any bettor can come up with a proof of that on the site รอยัล1688

    ReplyDelete
  4. New Games
    Gclub Is an online casino site that provides all the fun for the player. New games are easy to bet on, and you can bet directly on the site. All types of online gambling games are ready to entertain the users unlimited. The fun of online gambling games to provide more users, and also make money for all users. Bet on online fun games with fun at any time. No matter where you are, you can gamble on the online gambling sites. With our online games to win customers over the top. Not only this, our online casino games site also supports mobile betting, smartphone and easy to play money with online games that are open to the service users every time. Betting online games will not disappoint the users. Enjoy the taste and can meet the needs of modern gamblers to be good. The online gambling option is the gateway to riches. If you are an amateur today, you also have the privilege of earning a lot of money that will put you at risk. Gclub มือถือ

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you for sharing valuable information. Nice post. I enjoyed reading this post.

    ดูหนังเกาหลี

    ReplyDelete
  6. The best online casino games that give real money.
    GclubThe online gaming service provides you with unmatched levels of excitement. Win online games that give you a better bet. No matter what kind of online casino is available, it will make the path rich. Do you want to get rich with online casino games that will satisfy all your needs? Play free online games that you can play in real time with the mobile phone easily. In addition, our online games are open to unlimited online services without any holidays, when to use the service at all. Not only this, the online risky website also brings the games that are designed to be easy to understand and can be gambled over. In order to meet the needs of new gamblers or online gamblers. Win online games that serve you all as expert. And also bring good privileges with bonus promotions as well as overwhelming profits that will make you bet on our site worthwhile. The choice of fun with online gambling is always available. And provide money and wealth to customers. Royal1688

    ReplyDelete
  7. Online gambling has better entertainment.
    Goldclub SlotIt is a great way to start playing online gambling games at the best online gambling sites. Win a chance to win no limit online. The customer can risk the online fortune of our website whenever you want. Online gambling betting opportunities suitable for all types of gamblers. Gold to the joy. Every game is a gamble to be sure that the players are ready to bet. And can meet the needs of online gambling games are open all the time. And online gambling games where you choose to gamble. Online casino games more than 100 games to bring joy. Excited to you constantly. Online casino games and players will be more than entertainment. We offer online casino services that are all so popular and popular. Do not miss the chance to win live online and also promote. Special offer for new members and get up to 500 free credits to gamble. All bets are free to play. คาสิโนออนไลน์

    ReplyDelete
  8. Online Casinos Over Gambling Games
    Sbobet Our online casino is a web entertainment. To get online. To play games, bet. To save time to go to a real casino abroad. Because our site is easily accessible. Just have a cell phone or computer connected to the internet. This makes it easy to play anywhere anytime you want. It is also a site that is a leader in the fun for the player to join our site. In addition to the variety of games available. It will be fun to play with the game by simulation games. It comes from online casinos. There are also a lot of gaming bonuses where players can use their full capabilities to play with our site. And if there are problems or obstacles during the game. We have a 24 hour concierge and are always on hand. Please join us at our website. คาสิโน

    ReplyDelete
  9. จีคลับ Online gambling sites that can be played every day. Just like or want to gamble yourself all the time. Anyone who likes to gamble can play professionally. Have a play that anyone play. Can play in a friendly. Every day bets are fun and realistic bets.

    In addition, it is interesting to occasionally eat smoothies. It does not always benefit the body. If you do not like the way you drink it down. Green fruit juice. Full of benefits The smell of green and bitter taste, the drink will make your body can not absorb the benefits of the juice. If you do not want to lose fruits and vegetables, you should gradually drink it with a drink time of about 5-20 minutes, gradually sip gradually the body absorbs minerals and vitamins in the drink better.

    It is interesting to have a gambling game that will play every day. Gambling is like a good return every time. To play all. You can earn as you choose. It is a bet that will enjoy the things that people choose. Can play well with betting games to make more money. บาคาร่า

    ReplyDelete