Friday, December 2, 2016

The phylogenetics of equality


In previous articles (here and here*), I have argued that understanding phylogenetic trees is a core part of understanding evolution, and thus biology as a whole.  My last blogpost emphasized that using terms like basal and early-diverging to refer to taxa misrepresents what phylogenies communicate, and therefore leads to misunderstanding about how evolution works. I would guess that at least some readers thought, "Well is that so bad?  So what if I casually talk about a group of species as basal, and some in the audience incorrectly take this to mean less evolved? I just mean to say that they have retained some ancestral character states that I am interested in, and saying 'basal' as a shorthand is convenient."

Here I'd like to stress that contributing to ladder-of-life thinking** with sloppy tree-speaking has real tangible consequences, that we should take seriously, not just as biologists, but as citizens. Today Dan Lowe, friend in political philosophy sent me this article, written by a group of political scientists. They conducted a survey in which they asked 2000 participants (who were all white) to rank how 'evolved' they believe blacks and whites to be using a 0-100 scale placed below a popular depiction of the "ascent of man", an image which undoubtedly stirs up ladder-of-life thinking.***


Thirty-eight percent of the respondents rated blacks less evolved, with rationales including being more 'closer to' or 'like animals'.  The researchers report being surprised by these results, but I am not at all surprised.  Not just because we know that racism is prevalent in our country, but also because the public understanding of evolution, and particularly common ancestry, is depressingly low. 

Anyone who has been taught evolution (including tree thinking) should protest, no humans could ever be considered less 'evolved' than any other! All humans are more closely related to each other than to any other species, so none of us is 'closer to animals'! Anyway, all of us are animals. We belong to a branch of the tree that we call animals, and we are all equally related to other animals. Moreover, it is meaningless and biologically incorrect to consider any group of living organisms primitive or 'less evolved'. The real danger of any suggestion otherwise is that there is some biological or evolutionary rationale for racism.  We must be emphatic that there is not. 

Right now, many of us are thinking, what can we do to celebrate diversity and support inclusiveness? Here's one thing.  We can teach evolutionary biology and teach it well.  We can make a point to state that humans are part of evolutionary history just like everything else on the planet and the same principles that apply to other living organisms apply to us, too.  Just as we, as humans, are not more 'evolved' than a fern, none of the populations of humans are any more evolved than any other.

p.s. Thanks to Scott Taylor for comments.

p.p.s. Hateful comments in response to this post will be deleted.

*full text versions available from my website

**ladder-of-life thinking = thinking that promotes the idea that some species are more primitive (less 'evolved') than others; is associated with the ladder-of-life or the great chain of being (scala naturae), in which species are ranked from least to most evolved.  The ladder-of-life is not consistent with the tree-like structure of evolution. Although it has been rejected since Darwin, the vestiges of progressive thinking remain and are the source of many misconceptions regarding phylogenies. 

***I think I am going to have to write a post just about this depiction, and probably I'll make a new version, with a tree and all rotated around, that would have the opposite effect, i.e. stimulate tree-thinking instead of ladder-thinking. 


4 comments:

  1. Online casino games play real money.
    viva9988 It's a fun online gambling site that offers you great betting and gambling games. Gambling Games Online Win at the Risk of Experiencing the Most Popular Gambling Games Enjoy all the flavors with the experience of gambling that is different from other websites. Many online gambling games will bring customers to the joy of the mind. No matter how gambling online, it can be beneficial to you. Because of the online casino games, our online casino games are designed to bet on the internet and can be gambling games actually. Betting opportunities online casino games are ready to serve all time. At present, our online gaming website has launched online gambling games directly on the website. Or if you want to download the application to use the service on a smartphone. All bets are accepted online. Ready to make money for you every game. A rich player with online gambling games that gambles. Earn real profits and give full fun to continue. Enjoy the full enjoyment. จีคลับ

    ReplyDelete
  2. Online Casinos Website for entertainment
    Ruby888 Online Casino Site Is a new game That will not make you monotonous. And the drudgery anymore. You can also choose to play at any time, even if you have your own password. You can also accumulate points. The game of the casino online. There are a variety of games and ways and ways to play different. And there are recipes that will make you a lot of defeats. But how? Your own playability will determine whether you will win or lose each game. Online casinos also offer prizes and promotions, as well as good activities. Always give you Only you can join. In our online casino. You will be able to get that right now. And you will enjoy the game. You are the one who set the prize for yourself in an unknowingly boring. Do not decide whether the online casino is a scam or not. Because our online casinos actually pay real money, you get really rewarding. You do not have to be tired. And playing games is no longer a waste of time. If you are interested, please visit our website. IBCbet

    ReplyDelete
  3. จีคลับ Fun and entertaining sites to help gamblers. To play all areas. Stay at home at work. Fully playable. Gambling games do not require long holidays to enter gambling casinos. Can be played easily at home. Play professional. Make every bet every day fun, just like playing a game of betting. Which can be played selectively. Give good money There are daily gambling games. A fun and realistic gambler. Make good money this way. No need to be cumbersome to play all the games are always good.

    In addition, it is fun and interesting to give players gambling fun every time. Give a good return everywhere. Choose to play friendly. There are betting games to like. Who wants to make a good income for yourself, you can gamble as you choose. Come play every day, I will be satisfied every match. Gamblers can play professionally. You will like and satisfy all the competition. To play this way. Have fun every time. บาคาร่า

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your blog is very useful for me,Thanks for your sharing.

    หนังใหม่

    ReplyDelete